Skip to content

Top 8 Financial Moves to Make as a Pre-Med or Medical Student

2012 March 12

The following post is courtesy of Dr. Jim Dahle, MD who runs one of my favorite (and most useful) blogs out there: The White Coat Investor. He agreed to help my readers with some financial tips for pre-meds or current medical students.  Jim blogs about personal finance and investing for doctors, doctors-in-training, and other professionals. Take the time to favorite his blog, and subscribe to his monthly newsletter. 

1. Choose the cheapest school you can get into

The decision of which school to attend will have a greater impact on your finances for the next 5-20 years than any other decision other than who/if you marry and what specialty you choose to practice.  Choose wisely.  I’ll give you a hint–Most medical schools in this country provide a pretty comparable education.  Most of what you learn in medical school will come from what you teach yourself and the pearls dispensed to you freely by interns, residents, and other doctors you come into contact with.  Little of that learning is dependent on the school you choose.  Thus, choose the cheap state school if you can get into it.  Don’t forget that costs aren’t limited just to tuition and fees, but also to the local cost-of-living.  That school in Boston, New York, or San Francisco is going to cost you a lot more than the one in Omaha or Albuquerque.

2. Consider the merits of “scholarship” programs carefully

There are several organizations that would like to pay for your medical school in exchange for a commitment.  The military Health Professions Scholarship Program is the best known, but the US Public Health Service, Indian Health Services, and other private deals also exist.  None of these programs is a “scholarship” in the traditional sense of the word, and many a “scholarship winner” has later realized he would have been much better off, personally and financially, if he hadn’t been awarded the “scholarship.”  As a general rule, use these programs only if your career goal is to be a military doctor or a rural primary care doctor.  Choosing them for the money is almost surely a mistake you will regret.

3. Minimize your loan burden

Student loans suck and they’re getting worse.  Just a decade ago a medical student had access to much lower tuition he could pay with subsidized loans which he could refinance at a low rate shortly after graduation.  Now, tuition has skyrocketed, subsidized loans have disappeared, and loan refinancing has become pointless.  Now more than ever, you must minimize your loan burden.  Every dollar you spend of loan money is like three dollars, since that is what you will need to earn to pay for that dollar of consumption.  Take out as little in loans as you can, and spread it as far as you can.

4. Remember it’s easier to be poor when you’re young

When I was a medical student I was poor, and so were all my friends.  We used to drive to Red Rock, outside Las Vegas, to go rock climbing.  We would drive an economy car, bring and cook all our own food, and sleep in a ditch out in the desert for free.  We’d climb hard for a couple of days, then drive home.  I still go to Vegas to go climbing, but now I arrive in a gas-guzzling SUV, stay in a swanky hotel on the Strip, eat in $35 buffets, and go see $100 shows after the climbs.  The whole trip costs me less than a day’s work now, but it would have been a vast sum of money as a student.  Now is the time in your life to learn how to live cheaply.  Learn how to do without, to budget, and to defer gratification.  There IS light at the end of the tunnel, but wait until you get there before you start spending it.  Being poor sucks.  But it is far better to be young and poor than old and poor.  I’m reminded of this every time I interact with a local doctor who hates his job and is old enough to be retired.  He’s obviously working because he has to, and that’s an awful way to live out your golden years.

5. Don’t cheap out in the wrong places

Some people, especially pre-meds, but also medical students, cheap out in all the wrong places, such as getting into medical school.  Missing a year’s worth of earnings as an attending may cost you several hundred thousand dollars in career earnings.  Yet many pre-meds only apply to one or two medical schools because the applications are so expensive.  Or they take the MCAT the first time without doing any practice or a prep course “just to see how they’d do.”  Do it smart.  Do it right.  Do it once.  Getting into medical school is a numbers game.  Don’t be innumerate.  If you didn’t get enough interviews that you’re having to turn some down, you didn’t apply to enough schools.  If you feel like there’s something else you could have done to prep for the MCAT, you didn’t prepare enough.  Sell your car if you need to, but don’t expect to get into medical school if you only applied to one of them, applied late, or didn’t prepare for the only objective measurement available to medical schools.

6. Get a sugar momma

I keep seeing stories in the press about medical students prostituting on the side to pay for medical school.  I hope most of those are urban legends.  Nevertheless, don’t underestimate the benefits of splitting living costs with another person, especially one who has a job.  Now’s the time for your spouse to work full-time.  If he (or she) can cover your living costs, then your loans will be limited to just the cost of tuition.  Even if you’re not married, get a roommate or two to help save money, or better yet, live in your parent’s basement.  In fact, it is a little known secret that it is possible to hold down a job for much of medical school.  I even had a job as a 4th year student doing histories and physicals at a local surgicenter.  If you’re taking out enough loans to support a family of six for four years in addition to the costs of education, you will be limited in your specialty choices and future practice opportunities.

7. Begin your financial education

I advise residents and attendings to read one good financial book a year.  You might as well get started as a student.  While I wouldn’t recommend you worry much about investing until you get out of medical school, learning about insurance and budgeting could yield some hefty dividends.  Here’s my list of recommended books.

8. Pick a residency in a low cost-of-living city

There’s a lot that goes into how to make a rank list of residencies.  Residency pay is pretty similar, no matter where you go.  But don’t forget to consider the cost-of-living of the town you will do residency in.  I had friends who could easily support their family of 5 in a Midwestern city and others that couldn’t support themselves in the Bay Area.

There isn’t a lot you can do to improve your financial situation as a pre-med and medical school.  But don’t let that stop you from doing these 8 things that will improve it.

 

 

8 Responses Post a comment
  1. March 14, 2012

    RE: #8 (“Pick a residency in a low cost-of-living city”)

    While you would expect the cost of living in a Midwestern city to be very low as compared to other urban settings, realize that not all are created equal and some can actually be far more expensive than most other cities. The state of the economy over the past 1-2 years also plays a significant role.

    This is something I discovered after moving to my current city for residency. As a medical student, I had rotated in the Midwest before, so I was expecting/hoping to get a decent 1-bedroom in a safe location for no more than $500-600. Instead, I saw small 1-bedroom units in old buildings and no utilities included renting for over $1100! Even more shocking was that some of these apartments were not even in downtown and that many did not have any vacancies for several months. This was very surprising and is definitely having a large impact on my finances – an extra $500+/month I was hoping/expecting to be able to save by choosing my residency in a Midwest city is going towards my rent.

    • March 14, 2012

      Would you have gone to a different area of the country if you had known what you do now? Or is the midwest still the best “fit” for you?

  2. Alex permalink
    June 24, 2012

    Another move I would suggest, alongside with the suggestion of “doing things right…the first time around…” Many students these days are finding it beneficial to take some time off from school and in fact it seems to be the norm, despite how it’s labeled still as “non-traditional.” I would suggest that those who are in that gap year, to really use that time to read on financial planning, AND more importantly, use the wealth acquired in your gap year (hopefully) and start contributing to a Roth IRA.

    And, also…being on the matriculating end of the wall now, I will advise not to apply to too many reach schools…especially the non-OOS-friendly schools. I hail from WA state, and applying to UCSF, for example was the biggest waste of money for myself. There’s one thing to apply for a reach school, but it’s another to do the shotgun method when it comes down to reach schools, unless you’re an MCAT king with a stellar double/triple major-GPA with some sort of “Paul Farmer” type of storyline. Apply to schools that you feel reasonably realistic getting into, AND as it was mentioned above, apply to schools that have some reasonable standard of living. No use in getting sunken in with too much debt.

    • Anon permalink
      March 28, 2013

      As a “true” nontrad (older than 30 and applying this year), the kind of money that I might have made as a 22 year old fresh graduate in the year between college and medical school would have been enough to to put at best $2-3K in an IRA.

      I submit that it’d be much better for these kids to put that same money in an MMA and have a small but real cushion for things like residency applications and associated travel, etc. during medical school. There is no use having money in a tax advantaged account while one is accruing very unfavorable debt on the other side of the ledger.

  3. Matt permalink
    March 8, 2013

    I took the HPSP Scholarship as a 2nd year Medical Student and had 3 years of medical school paid for. My experience has been a positive one thus far. I’m currently serving my last year of payback as a flight surgeon and will find out where I match in Anesthesiology soon. Financially, I was 108,000 in debt from undergrad and 1 year of medical school. Over the course of my three years (1 year internship + 2 years of serving as a flight surgeon) I have been able to pay it all off. I will start my residency debt free, albeit 3 years behind. As an
    Anesthesiologist I will have missed out on 3 years of making a 300,000 salary, which you can easily see has put me behind financially. That is if I had gone straight through and decided to make the same financial decisions I have until this point. However, I will have spent three years doing way cooler stuff than most of my peers. My application was also strengthened by my military experience and I was highly sought after by residency programs. For those considering primary care I would strongly consider the HPSP scholarship with the caveat you have some interest in service to the military. For those who might make more as a specialist, it’s probably not worth it from a purely financial perspective. Then again that may be changing with implementation of Obama Care.

    • March 9, 2013

      Thanks for the great reply Matt. And thanks for serving. Best of luck to you.

  4. Pri permalink
    May 10, 2013

    Hi A!
    When you say cheapest do you mean without loans? As of now I pay 7.5g a year and loans of 8g a year. Sometimes I do feel that this is kind of expensive, but is it worth like transferring over to a cheap school where the quality of education may not be as great?

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. 8 Financial Tips for Medical Students | The White Coat Investor- Investing And Personal Finance Information For Physicians, Dentists, Residents, Students, And Other Highly-Educated Busy Professionals

Leave a Reply

Note: You may use basic HTML in your comments. Your email address will not be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS